What is going on with the two-story building on Fifth Avenue South near Park Street? It was gutted in the summer of 2025 and has looked frozen ever since. A reader put that question to the Naples Press "Tim Aten Knows" column this fall. The answer runs through the city's building code.
The building at 649-663 Fifth Ave. S. sits on the north side of the Avenue, just west of Inn on Fifth. Its emptiness traces back to one decision by the City of Naples: the renovation was reviewed as new construction. The tenants are ready and their restaurant permits are approved, but the building's own permit has been the hold-up. When the Avenue lights the Sugden Plaza tree on Dec. 4, this block will still be dark. The restaurants planned for it are now aimed at a post-season opening in 2027.
Who Is Waiting Behind the Plywood
The building was home to L'Olivo and Roma, two Italian spots. Feibi Gouda runs the project with her husband, Raafat Bishai, and her brothers, Gerges Eskandr and George Salama. They closed L'Olivo last year before the interior demolition. They plan to reopen the space as Riva Mediterranean Restaurant & Lounge at 651 Fifth Ave. S. Zanu Sushi Bar will go next door, where Roma's pizza used to be.
The family has a long history downtown. Gouda and Bishai have run restaurants in the Naples area for 25 years. They started with Falafel Grill, which had locations in Naples and North Naples. They have also run Opa, Grouper Grille and a cigar bar on Fifth Avenue South. L'Olivo ran for more than six years in a space where they had already owned South Ave Restaurant and Crispy Seafood & Wine Bar.
The building is owned by Aspen-based M Development, doing business as NECO 649-663 5th Avenue South LLC. Construction was supposed to start in December 2025, and the family had planned to open in early 2026.
Why a Remodel Became New Construction
Gouda told Naples Press she thought it would be a simple remodel. City staff saw substantial redevelopment. That meant the 60-year-old building was treated as new, and everything had to meet the current building code.
That decision brought a long list of engineering questions. The city questioned the structural engineer's analysis of dry floodproofing. It asked how the building would hold up against the sideways pressure of floodwater and against buoyancy. The developer hired a geologist and drilled soil borings to answer the city's questions and meet FEMA requirements for buildings below base flood elevation. The city sent the permit application back several times with comments.
According to Naples Press, which printed the letter's language, a stormwater corrections letter dated May 7 went to the owner and to the contractor, Levisse Management LLC of Miami. It quoted the city's definition of remodeling or redevelopment under Ordinance 2021-14654.
The letter also asked for the total square footage being rebuilt across both permits, because the two restaurant spaces had been filed separately. The city needed that combined figure to review the whole project.
That is how the city applied its rule to this one building, as Naples Press reported it. It is general information, not legal or permitting advice. Anyone planning their own renovation should confirm how the rules apply with the city and a licensed professional.
"We're losing the second season."
That is how Gouda summed it up to Naples Press. The family's original plan had the space missing only one season. In the same Oct. 16, 2026 column, she said she hoped to have the construction permit by the end of October. She expects six to eight months of work once it is issued, which puts the opening after the 2027 season. "When I get the permit, I'm going to do as much as I can because everything is ready," she told the paper.
What the Rebuilt Front Will Look Like
The building's new face is already approved. On Oct. 27, 2026, the city's Design Review Board approved a revised version of the façade plan presented by Architects Unlimited. The updated plans add planters, louvered privacy walls to hide electrical and mechanical equipment, and a new retaining wall for dry floodproofing. They also adjust some second-floor details. The building will not get taller, and the arched roof over the second-floor balcony stays. The approval comes with a standard landscape certification and a recommendation to soften the rear entries with plantings. Citizen Portal's summary of the meeting has the details.
The floodproofing that held up the permit will be visible from the sidewalk once the building opens. The new retaining wall is there for dry floodproofing, and the planters and screening respond to the slope of the site. The second-floor tenants have not been announced.
Downtown's Holidays Start on Third Street
The holiday calendar is the other reason this block stands out. Third Street South starts celebrating almost two weeks before the Avenue does.
| Date | Where | What |
|---|---|---|
| Thanksgiving week, Tue–Sat | Third Street South | Live music 5–8 p.m., snowfall at 7 p.m., shops open until 7 p.m. |
| Mon., Nov. 23, 6–9 p.m. | Third Street South | Naples Tree Lighting; street closed to traffic |
| Nov. 25–Dec. 23 | Third Street South shops | Letters to Santa available |
| Fri., Dec. 4, starting 5 p.m. | Fifth Avenue South | Christmas Walk, Sugden Plaza tree lighting, Avenue Dining |
| December, Thu–Sat | Third Street South | Snowfall at 7 p.m.; live Christmas music Thu and Fri, 5–8 p.m. |
| Sat., Dec. 12, 1–3 p.m. | Near Sea Salt, Third Street South | Santa Paws photos for leashed pets |
Third Street South's 49th Christmas on Third also has a new tradition this year. The district has been named a North Pole Delivery District. Children can pick up a Letter to Santa at participating shops and drop it in one of two mailboxes, one at Fleischmann Plaza near Gattle's and one at Santa's Workshop near Sea Salt. There is no programming on Thanksgiving Day or Christmas Day.
The city lists the 2026 Fifth Avenue South Christmas Walk and Avenue Dining for Friday, Dec. 4, from 5 to 10 p.m. The Fifth Avenue South business district bills it as a two-day festival running into Dec. 5. Its lineup includes the official tree lighting in Sugden Plaza, a living nativity, a skating rink, live music and Santa Claus.
Avenue Dining is the part of the night where the gap shows most. Nobody will be serving dinner on Christmas Walk night in the space that held L'Olivo and Roma.
Where the Avenue's Newer Tables Are
Several of downtown's newer places are ready for a holiday-week dinner before the snowfall or the tree lighting.
- Barrio Taqueria, 539 Fifth Ave. S., opened Feb. 18. The owner is Sal Muñoz.
- All Too Well Gourmet Sandwiches, 795 Fifth Ave. S., opened Feb. 12. The owner and chef is Mitchell Jamra.
- Annie's Bistro, Bar & Bakery opened May 15, Naples Press reported, in the first phase of the Olde Naples Hotel at 200 Broad Ave. S., between Third Street South and Gordon Drive. The hotel is a venture of the Camalier family and Ocean Properties Hotels & Resorts.
Naples Press covered the two Fifth Avenue openings as more affordable additions to the Avenue. Annie's sits within walking distance of the Third Street tree lighting, so it works for the Nov. 23 evening. Barrio and All Too Well are both on Fifth for the Dec. 4 walk.
For 649-663 Fifth Ave. S., Gouda's own estimate puts six to eight months of work between the day the building permit is issued and the first plates at Riva and Zanu.
Jill Nicholas watches these downtown blocks closely, from the permits and design approvals to the storefronts that change hands. If you own near Fifth Avenue South or Third Street South and want to know what a stalled redevelopment nearby could mean for your property, Request a Consultation and Jill will walk you through it.